Posted by Darwin to Jesus on 16th April 2025 in Atheism | Fyodor Dostoevsky,Dostoyevsky,Atheism,morality
...“No. It
has no context, it just happens to exist for no reason, and even though we don’t have access to it, we believe this rule says your monitors are too big.”
This is atheist moral realism.
It claims that objective moral facts exist, but they come from nowhere, are grounded in nothing, and are backed by no authority.
It’s like walking into an abandoned building, seeing graffiti on the wall that says “Don’t wear red,” and thinking you’re somehow obligated to obey it.
Even if the rule exists in some strange metaphysical way, why does it have any binding force on you?
You’d be right to say:
“That
has nothing to do with me, this company,...